Start with the size of the source

Magnitude summarizes an earthquake’s size rather than the shaking at one address. Moment magnitude is based on seismic moment, which combines the fault area that slipped, the amount of slip and the rigidity of the rock. Other magnitude methods use different features of recorded seismic waves. A magnitude label therefore belongs with its scale. Treating every reported value as a Richter measurement loses information about how the source was estimated, especially when comparing earthquakes measured with different methods or historical records.

Sources: quake-size

A revised estimate is not a changing earthquake

An early magnitude estimate may be revised as more records arrive and more detailed analysis becomes possible. Some seismic waves have not yet reached distant instruments when an initial estimate is issued, and some networks deliver data later. USGS also reviews events when assembling archival catalogs. The number can consequently change without implying that the original rupture has changed. In a comparison, preserve the reporting agency, magnitude type and version or update time instead of combining preliminary and reviewed values as though their status were identical.

Sources: quake-revisions

The path and the ground change the shaking

Intensity varies across the area affected by a single event. Distance from the ruptured fault matters, but so do rupture direction, depth and local geology. Two stations at similar distances can record different motions because the material beneath them responds differently. A map of intensity is therefore not expected to form perfect rings around an epicenter. Nor can a magnitude alone specify the shaking in a particular neighborhood: the source measurement and the local ground response answer related but different questions.

Sources: quake-size

Japan’s intensity values come from instruments

JMA’s seismic intensity table includes categories such as 5 Lower and 5 Upper. The agency states that its announced intensities generally come from meters on the ground or the first floor of low-rise buildings. The accompanying descriptions of human reactions and possible damage explain those categories; they are not the observations used to assign the instrumental value. This distinction matters when reading a report: an intensity recorded at a station does not claim that every described effect occurred throughout the surrounding city.

Sources: quake-jma

Equal intensity does not guarantee equal damage

JMA cautions that sites with the same reported intensity can suffer different damage. The period and duration of the motion, construction characteristics and underground conditions all contribute. Even within a building, the motion can differ by floor and position, with stronger movement possible upstairs. A station’s intensity should therefore remain attached to its site and observing context. It is evidence about the shaking there, not a building-by-building inspection or a universal forecast of what every structure at that intensity will experience.

Sources: quake-jma

Keep the scale name when comparing reports

The Modified Mercalli scale used in the United States has a different basis: it ranks observed effects on people, structures and the landscape. Lower levels emphasize felt experiences, while higher levels involve damage evidence. Its Roman numerals are not interchangeable with Japanese intensity categories simply because both describe shaking. When a report says an earthquake was “a six,” the missing label is decisive. Ask whether it means a magnitude estimate or a named intensity at a stated place before attempting any comparison.

Sources: quake-mmi