The instrument moves with the ground

An inertial seismic sensor compares a ground-attached structure with an internal mass that resists changes in motion. That relative behavior becomes an electrical signal. A force-balance accelerometer adds feedback that pushes the mass toward its reference position; the feedback system allows ground acceleration to be measured. Modern recordings therefore are not simply pictures of a pen following the ground. The sensor, its feedback and its recorder all sit between physical motion and the waveform eventually drawn on a screen for a reader.

Sources: seis-usgs

Velocity and acceleration describe different aspects of motion

Many broadband instruments have a response that is approximately proportional to ground velocity across a specified frequency band. Strong-motion accelerometers instead target acceleration, with designs suited to large-amplitude shaking. Velocity describes how quickly position changes; acceleration describes how quickly velocity changes. Even for the same motion, those two histories have different shapes and units. EarthScope’s instrument guide distinguishes the sensor families by their operating bands and purposes. “Broadband” does not mean equally responsive at every frequency, and a sensor’s exact model still matters.

Sources: seis-types

Raw counts are not a shared physical ruler

An archived waveform may initially be expressed in counts, the numbers produced by digitizing the instrument’s electrical output. The same count on two channels need not represent the same ground motion. EarthScope’s data guidance distinguishes an approximate sensitivity conversion from full instrument correction: a sensitivity is associated with particular units and a reference frequency. Dividing by that number can help display a trace, but does not describe the response everywhere. A larger uncorrected trace is therefore insufficient evidence of larger physical motion.

Sources: seis-counts

A response has both gain and timing behavior

Instrument-response descriptions track amplitude and phase as functions of frequency. Amplitude response says how strongly a component of the motion appears in the output; phase response describes its timing relationship. EarthScope’s response-evaluation service can represent a channel in displacement, velocity or acceleration units and produce amplitude–phase plots. This makes the comparison question specific: which physical quantity, which frequency interval and which channel configuration are being compared? Merely stretching two plotted traces to the same height does not put their response functions on equal terms.

Sources: seis-response

An off-scale peak is an instrument limit

The recording chain also has a finite amplitude range. USGS describes how limited dynamic range can drive recordings off-scale, and how high- and low-gain sensors help keep different-sized signals within range. Once an interval has been recorded off-scale, changing a plot’s vertical scale cannot recreate its missing peak shape. This explains a practical reason to combine complementary sensors at a station: sensitivity to small signals and capacity for large ones are separate requirements, even when both instruments are listening to the same earthquake.

Sources: seis-usgs

The metadata belongs beside the waveform

A useful comparison keeps the network, station, location, channel and observation date together with the trace. EarthScope’s counts guidance uses all of those identifiers to obtain the relevant sensitivity, units and sample rate. The date matters because the correct response belongs to the instrument configuration for that recording. An apparent disagreement can then be tested as a question about units or response rather than judged from appearance alone. Only after that translation do differences in the physical waveforms become the subject of interpretation.

Sources: seis-counts